Candidates
for Antibiotic Treatment. Antibiotic
regimens that eradicate H. pylori are now known to cure ulcers
and reduce the risk for both peptic and duodenal ulcer bleeding. One
computer analysis even suggests that eliminating H. pylori
infection could significantly increase the lifespan of certain
individuals with peptic ulcers, such as younger adults.
Antibiotics are clearly indicated for patients with strong
evidence, particularly from endoscopy, for both ulcers and H. pylori.
Some experts even recommend antibiotics for patients who have dyspepsia
and evidence of H. pylori from blood or breath tests even if the
presence of ulcers has not been confirmed. Many believe that persistent
dyspepsia is such a strong risk factor for ulcers that eliminating the
bacteria in infected people may not only prevent them in many people but
also lower the risk for stomach cancer.
Drug
Regimens.
At least five effective drug combinations are being used with success
rates as high as 90% although cost varies widely. The best results are
achieved using two antibiotics and a drug called a proton pump
inhibitor, usually omeprazole (Prilosec), which suppresses acid
production. A typical triple-drug regimen consists of omeprazole,
clarithromycin (Biaxin), and amoxicillin. Other effective regimens
substitute metronidazole (Flagyl) for clarithromycin or amoxicillin. ( H.
pylori resistance to metronidazole is increasing, however.) Such
three-drug regimens are well tolerated and effective, but very
expensive. A less costly three-drug regimen using omeprazole, Bismuth
(Pepto-Bismol), and tetracycline may be a good alternative, although it
is less effective, side effects can be very distressing, and many
patients cannot tolerate it.
Side
Effects and Noncompliance.
Although antibiotic treatment is very effective against both gastric and
duodenal ulcers, patient compliance is poor. The triple-drug
regimens are complicated and require many pills a day. Side effects from
one or more of these drugs occur in up to 30% of patients. Cases of
severe diarrhea have occurred during treatment. One study indicates that
the long-term side effects of treatment include weight gain. Eliminating
the bacteria also may increase risk for gastroesophageal reflux
esophagitis (a cause of severe heartburn).
Follow-up
and Success.
Cure rates after antibiotic treatments range from 70% to 90%. Symptom
relief after treatment does not always indicate success, nor, on the
other hand, does persistence of dyspepsia necessarily mean that
treatment has failed. Follow-up testing for the bacterial should be
conducted no sooner than four weeks after therapy. (Test results before
that time may not be accurate.) Studies are indicating that, at least in
developed countries, once the bacteria is eliminated, ulcers recur at an
annual rate of less than 10%. (Reinfection with the bacteria may be
possible, particularly in areas where the incidence of H. pylori
is very high and sanitary conditions are poor.)
Other Treatments for
Ulcers Caused by H. Pylori
Elderly patients with ulcers caused by H. pylori but
who cannot tolerate the side effects of the antibiotic therapy may
continue to benefit from H2 blockers, the older treatment for peptic
ulcers. Some experts recommend H2 blockers for people who
test positive for H. pylori but have symptoms only of dyspepsia
and no sign of peptic ulcers. Their argument is based on reducing costs;
young people who meet this criteria but who have other risk factors for
ulcers should discuss options with their physician. Some researchers are
also concerned that eradicating H. Pylori may not be effective against
bleeding episodes from existing ulcers and that H2 blockers will remain
important for treating this condition. By decreasing acid production,
the body has the opportunity to heal itself. H2 blockers temporarily
heal up to 95% of ulcers after eight weeks, but they do not prevent
recurrence of ulcers. One study, for example, showed that long-term
therapy with the H2 blocker ranitidine (Zantac) significantly
prevented recurring bleeding in people who had experienced severe
hemorrhaging from non-NSAID-induced ulcers.